Back to Home
Home >> Biotechnology /Genomics and Intellectual Property >>Patenting of Biological Material >>Patenting of Biological Material Introduction
Back to Home

Patenting of Biological Material
In previous chapter, we discussed the different intellectual properties and the rights available to protect these properties, particularly when they involve biotechnological processes or products. Of these properties, patents are the most important.
Even though, patenting of inventions arising from basic research (commercially significant) were earlier considered unfashionable or ethically dubious, it is now viewed more favourably by many. Different countries have different patent laws, which can be modified from time to time.
Patents are granted or complaints of infringement of these patents decided by courts in accordance with the patent law of the concerned country. The life forms could not be patented before 1980, when the discovery of an oil-eating bacterium (Pseudmonas)by a non-resident Indian scientist (Ananda Chakrabarty), was the first case of a life form to be patented in USA by a multinational corporation. A later patent issued for 'oncomouse' was another milestone in patenting of life forms.

The issue of granting patents to life forms has also been discussed in India. Even though, there are arguments against patenting life forms particularly in developing world, but the advent of biotechnology has made it necessary that patents of life forms be allowed, because in its absence, commercial firms would not like to invest in biotechnology research. In this connection, there has been a lot of debate in India, because in recent years, USA has been pressurizing India. through the multinational forum of GATT (General Agreement of Trade. and Tariffs) and later WTO to change many of its laws pertaining to patents (as discussed in previous chapter).
In view of recent biotechnological developments, the discussion has now progressed beyond merely the question of whether living organisms can be patented, and is now concerned with establishing solid criteria for granting patents. The existing patent laws are also being re-interpreted with regard to biological meterial.

In India, the patent law till recently was based on India Patent Act of 1970, which has been reviewed for change due to international pressure. As mentioned in the previous chapter, the 1970 patent law did not allow product patents on foods, chemicals, drugs, and pharmaceuticals.
Only process patents were granted in these areas. Therefore, the same product could be produced by an alternative process, which was more cost effective. In case of dispute, the burden of proving that the product was not produced by alternative process, laid with the original patent - holder, wholodged the complaint. The patent laws in USA and Europe, however differed from those in India.